Book Review
Shivanand Kanavi
(appeared in Rediff.com: http://www.rediff.com/business/column/billionaires-have-always-called-the-shots-in-india/20180912.htm)
(appeared in Rediff.com: http://www.rediff.com/business/column/billionaires-have-always-called-the-shots-in-india/20180912.htm)
Bollywood version of India’s economic history
The Billionaire Raj
A journey through India’s gilded age
By James Crabtree, (Harper Collins 2018)
James Crabtree’s “Billionaire Raj” (HarperCollins 2018) makes
racy reading with all the details he fills in the vignettes of the characters
he chooses to sketch.
A veritable tour de force through the last decade in India.
Crabtree’s book is a recollection of encounters with movers and shakers of India.
Some are based on direct contact as Mumbai correspondent for Financial Times
and others on secondary sources. They read like graphic notes for a future
novel or even a Bollywood script. In fact he calls Indian billionaires as
Bollygarchs to rhyme with Russia’s Oligarchs.
His sketches include:
- · Melancholic Mallya in his current London residence—a genuine scoop of sorts considering no Indian journalist has met him in London;
- · Navin Jindal and his grandiose “country of his dreams” overlooking a rusting steel and power plant;
- · Portly Adani quietly but surely climbing up the ladder;
- · Ballari baron Janardhan Reddy and the extravagance of his daughters’ wedding;
- · Success of Mukesh Ambani and his 27 floors of excess--Antilia;
- · Holographic impression of Narendra Modi since he could not get to meet him in person;
- · Lagadapati Rajagopal of Lanco Infratech, the honourable former MP from Vijayawada, (if you are still clueless then he is the one who used pepper spray in Lok Sabha in 2014 to get it adjourned);
- · Arnab Goswami and his shrill rabble rousing in “Jerry Springer comes to FOX news” style “THE NATION WANTS TO KNOW” shows;
- · IPL folklore: Lalit Modi, N Srinivasan, BCCI and even Shanthkumar Shreesanth’s shenanigans included;
- · The rotund bull of Dalal Street, Rakesh Jhunjhunwala;
And so on and so forth.
They are readable and borderline voyeuristic. He interweaves
these anecdotes with ponderous quotes on inequality studies, campaign financing
in Indian elections, conglomerates and their opaque finances, crony capitalism,
sports betting etc.
He begins the book and ends it saying Crony capitalism and
ostentatious billionaires are a phase every country has gone through in its
capitalist journey and hopefully the glaring inequalities, crony capitalism and
all-round corruption will moderate with India’s own clean-up programs and an
era of benign Progressive Capitalism. He is ambivalent on whether Modi or
Kejriwal or some new political player will do it.
If you are looking for the answers to how do billionaires in
India actually rule (Raj remember is rule)? You may be disappointed.
He ignores the emergence of nexus between business and
politics going back to 1920’s in India and talks of it as a new child of 21st
century India.
A Hundred years ago too billionaires played their part. Later
many of them thrived in the post independence economy. Then too billionaires played
a role in planning the “planned economy” despite loudly denouncing the “License
and Permit Raj” for public consumption.
This was admitted by no less than Dr Manmohan Singh in 2004
when he said, “As a student of economics in the 1950s and later as a
practitioner in government, I was greatly impressed by the ‘Bombay Plan’ (authored
by JRD Tata, G D Birla, Purushottamdas Thakurdas, Lala Sri Ram, Kasturbhai
Lalbhai, A D Shroff & John Mathai) of 1944. When we read it today, nearly
60 years later, we see how relevant many of the central propositions of the
Bombay Plan remain. In those days, it was an unprecedented document. It is
worthy of emphasis that nowhere in the developing world had a group of
businessmen come together to draw up such a long-term plan for a country.”
Dr. Man Mohan Singh continued, “The Bombay Plan laid great
emphasis on public investment in social and economic infrastructure, in both
rural and urban areas, it emphasized the importance of agrarian reform and
agricultural research, in setting up educational institutions and a modern
financial system. Above all, it defined the framework for India's transition
from agrarian feudalism to industrial capitalism. In many ways, it encapsulated
what all subsequent Plans have tried to achieve.”
So its disconcerting that like most pop historians, Crabtree
too calls the period 1947-1991 as “socialist” or even “crony socialism”,
whatever that means.
To his credit, Crabtree deftly traces the growth of debt
crisis in corporate India, a topic he doggedly followed as the Mumbai
correspondent of Financial Times despite official
obfuscation. He traces it to opacity of conglomerates and their conjuring up
multi-billion dollar projects with nil or very small equity of their own in the
go-go years and the banking system that “overlooked” due diligence.
Curiously he mentions only in passing that there are also
“good billionaires”, as in IT and Pharma but does not portray them at all.
After all India’s global image got a boost in 21st century primarily
because of IT and Pharma (exports nearly $140 billion 2017-18).
It’s a good read. With his eye for detail I hope he writes a
novel soon on a crony capitalist or Bollygarch if you will!
-------------------------------------------------------
(Shivanand Kanavi is a Theoretical Physicist, Business
Journalist, Author, Former VP at TCS, Currently Consulting Editor Business
India and Adjunct Faculty at NIAS, Bengaluru. He can be reached at: skanavi@gmail.com
; Twitter: @shivanandkanavi, Blog: www.reflections-shivanand.blogspot.com/
)
